Forum

The Brownstoner Forum is for the site's users to ask and answer questions of local concern. You must be registered member to post, please refrain from self-promotional postings.

Sewer and Water Line Contract: Is it Worth It?

11:00 AM 02/07/2013

 

I just got a promotion in the mail from the NYC Water Board offering a contract for Sewer line maintenance and repair (thought a private company) for a monthly fee of $11.    I have a very old townhouse and never had any work done on the sewer.  Is it worth it signing up for this deal?  How often water main or sewer line breaks?  I have a Heat and Air Conditioning contract with National Grid and found it extremely helpful, I wonder if I need to do the same with the water and sewer line.
Any thoughts on this would be appreciated.
Thank you.
 

 

 

15 answers
  • vote

    I haven't decided yet but am tending to think I'll take it.  Most of the people I've spoken w/ are also leaning that way.

    11:23 AM 02/07/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    I signed up for it. If the water or sewer lines go on my house, I face an expensive proposition in repairing them. The lines go from my house across a wide sidewalk to the mains running on the opposite side of the the street. I feel the cost of the insurance is inexpensive enough to justfy ending my exposure to the cost of this repair. 

    2:47 PM 02/07/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    I signed up for it. If the water or sewer lines go on my house, I face an expensive proposition in repairing them. The lines go from my house across a wide sidewalk to the mains running on the opposite side of the the street. I feel the cost of the insurance is inexpensive enough to justfy ending my exposure to the cost of this repair. 

    2:47 PM 02/07/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    This is great info, did notknow this option was available.  Like you kid, my service main is on opposite side of street.  Will be looking into this as well.  Thanks all!

    2:52 PM 02/07/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    A lawyer I know has suggested looking into the 'exclusions' - maybe even to the extent of phoning to pin down what is actually covered.

    3:24 PM 02/07/2013 | -1 Votes

     

     

    Comments (1)

    • that was my main concern. my husband and i received this in the mail last night. we're down in the Gowanus and this actually happened to a neighbor of ours last summer. It cost him tens of thousands to repair. however, i want to know exactly what does and does not get covered. if you come across some good info please do share with us.

      4:24 PM 02/07/2013

          
  • vote

    This is insurance and not really a maintenance contract. I doubt they will do anything until there is a problem. The exclusions seem big enough to drive a truck through -- anything done by you or third parties. It really looks like it just covers old age, which in this City I suspect is a major cause of problems. Not sure about damage from tree roots and the like. Anyway, I signed up online. They said I would receive an email in a couple days confirming. After a week I called and they had no record of me. I had a screen print of the application acceptance but that did not help. The help line person started the process again, along with the 30 day clock before coverage become applicable. I think they are being overwhelmed with applications. 

    9:00 AM 02/08/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    Here is a link to the AWR's policy regarding this offer:
    http://www.nyc.gov/html/dep/pd...
    Below is the summary of what is NOT covered under the program:

    7. What Repairs Are Not Covered?
    AWR will not pay for any of the following:
    • Repairing anything that occurred before the 
    Effective Date.
    • Repairing anything not resulting from normal wear 
    and usage.
    • Repairing anything caused by You or any third parties.
    • Repairing anything in any home that is vacant due to 
    renovation, remediation or construction.
    • Repairing anything caused by natural acts or 
    disasters, such as earthquakes, floods, hurricanes, 
    landslides or sinkholes.
    • Repairing anything caused by defective materials 
    that have been the subject of a recall or class action 
    litigation.
    • Repairing any clog or blockage of Your Water Line.
    • Repairing any Water Line not connected to DEP’s 
    water system.
    • Repairing any interior pipes beyond the main shut-off 
    valve inside Your Home.
    • Repairing any connections and/or extensions to 
    the Water Line, such as water lines to sprinklers, 
    irrigation systems, pressure-reducing valves or 
    back-flow preventers.
    • Repairing anything required by any local, state or 
    federal agency inspection, unless otherwise covered 
    by this Agreement.
    • Repairing any openings made in walls, ceilings or 
    surfaces inside Your Home for AWR’s independent 
    contractor to access Your Water Line.
    • Repairing any third party’s water line that is attached 
    to Your Water Line.
    • Restoring any gardens, shrubs, trees or structures.
    • Restoring any sidewalks, curbs, driveways, roads or 
    other paved surfaces that are not required by permit or 
    New York City Department of Transportation rules and 
    regulations to be repaired or restored.
    • Moving any water meter at the time of repair, unless 
    required by code.
    • Relocating any section of Your Water Line, unless 
    necessary to complete a repair.
    • Updating any non-leaking Water Line to meet code, 
    law or ordinance requirements.
    • Removing any items necessary to access Your 
    Water Line, such as debris, trash, rocks, cars or 
    temporary structures.
    • Remediating or cleaning any hazardous substance or 
    pollutant, such as mold or asbestos.
    • Thawing any frozen section of Your Water Line.
    • Excavating Your Home's Foundation or slab in order to 
    access any section of Your Water Line.
    • Repairing, replacing or cleaning any portion of Your 
    Home or its contents that are damaged by leaks or 
    breaks to Your Water Line.
    • Paying any costs caused by a leak or break in Your 
    Water Line , such as lost water costs, relocation costs, 
    storage costs or temporary housing costs.
    • Paying any damages caused by a leak or break in Your 
    Water Line such as lost time, lost use of Your Home 
    or its contents or any damages due to any special 
    circumstances or conditions.

    9:22 AM 02/08/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    These 2 seem to be in conflict of each other. But I ain't no lawyer.
    • Repairing anything that occurred before the 
    Effective Date.
    • Repairing anything not resulting from normal wear 
    and usage.

    11:17 AM 02/08/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    My reading on this is that it just protects the incoming water supply line and NOT the sewer line. The sewer line, from my experience, is the one that usually goes. Anyone else have view on this?

    12:15 PM 02/08/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

    Comments (2)

    • $3.99 per month for water line protection and $7.99 per month for sewer line protection http://www.nyc.gov/html/dep/ht...

      12:34 PM 02/08/2013

          
    • Apologies: didn't notice that the link to the actual agreement was broken out into 2 separate parts; water and sewer.

      12:47 PM 02/08/2013

          
  • vote

    I think it comes down to the risk and your ability to shell out for a big unexpected repair. If there's a ~1% chance per year of a ~$5k water line break then $50 a year isn't unreasonable. And if there's a ~1% / year chance of a $10k repair of a sewer line then $100 sounds OK. If you can pay the bill without a big hardship, then self insuring is OK too, especially if you know the lines have been replaced in the last decade or 2, as opposed to 100 year old lines.
     

    12:41 PM 02/08/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    Question on one of the exclusions in the sewer portion:
    EXCLUSION:Repairing any Sewer Line connected to a nonconforming drain line, such as a basement or storm drain system.
    I have a 100+ year old house and the 4" sewer line runs horizontal and exposed in the basement. Also the roof drainage system (gutters down through leaders) feed into the system in the back yard. This is the original way the house was built. Is this what they are referring to in this exclusion? Thank you.

    1:13 PM 02/08/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

    Comments (1)

    • master plumber: Would you be so kind as to weigh in on this. Thank you

      1:39 PM 02/08/2013

          
  • vote

    master plumber: Would you be so kind as to weigh in on this. Thank you

    1:32 PM 02/08/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    we replaced our water main - so would this refer to the "incoming water line". Would it still make sens to have this coverage?

    2:34 PM 02/08/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    we replaced our water main - so would this refer to the "incoming water line". Would it still make sens to have this coverage?

    2:34 PM 02/08/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    The main issue, to me, seems to be the age of your sewer (and water lines). I have
    read that they have a working life of 50 years. Of course there are other
    issues but without this knowledge is "the only unknown that we do know" (thank
    you Donald) is they wear out out at about fifty.

    Given this how do you find out how old our lines are?
    I-card? DOB?

    Has anyone a suggestion as to how we find out how old our individual lines are?

    4:28 PM 02/22/2013 | 0 Votes

     

     

Answer