Forum

The Brownstoner Forum is for the site's users to ask and answer questions of local concern. You must be registered member to post, please refrain from self-promotional postings.

Painting vs. Staining a wooden deck?

10:21 PM 04/16/2012

 

What is the difference? I want to paint the floor of the deck in my yard. 
Can I just buy exterior paint in Mahogany or Burgundy and paint the floor of my wooden deck? Or do I have to sand it first and then stain it?
I'm thinking of using Behr Exterior paint for this DIY project. Does anyone have experience with this brand of paint for exterior? Is there something else you would recommend for painting a wooden deck? 
Thanks for the feedback. 

 

 

11 answers
  • vote

    Here is a pic of the yard deck  http://imgur.com/a/qN0bh 

    10:33 PM 04/16/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

    Comments (1)

  • vote

    I think i don't know how to  paint. But I think u can sand it first and then stain it.

    11:14 PM 04/16/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    i'm not an expert, but I don't think most paint will last long on a horizontal deck surface.  Paint sits on top of the wood, and rain pooling over a period of time will seperate the paint from the wood.  Then removing it / stripping it will be a huge PITA.  Use something that penetrates, like a stain or stain like product combined with a topcoat sealer.  If I were you, i would walk into a sherman williams dealer and get real advice, not rely on the big box "help".  The Behr stains actually performed well in consumer reports tests, right behind sherman williams, but paying a little extra for the advice in your case could be worth its weight in gold.  

    12:24 AM 04/17/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

    Comments (1)

    • thank for this answer. very useful.

      6:05 PM 04/17/2012

          
  • vote

    I agree with slopemope about not using paint on a deck. When it fails (and it will), you will have a major mess. I use a penetrating oil/stain, with UV protection, on all of my decks. Since you want a dark color, go with a translucent stain, but don't buy it at HD. I think that Benjamin Moore makes what you need.
    You need to clean the deck first (if you pressure wash, dial down the pressure), but sanding would give you the best results.
    Steve

    6:35 AM 04/17/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

    Comments (1)

    • i live by the benjamin moore in slope. they never seem to be open though. ill check out bay ridge. thanks!

      6:16 PM 04/17/2012

          
  • vote

    also they make paint that is "floor paint" which I assume means something in there to help you not slip. you'd need more of that outside, where things get slippery.
    if you want it dark, why not try stain and then seal with waterproof wood stuff?

    11:22 AM 04/17/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

    Comments (1)

    • you guys have convinced me that staining is the way to go. thanks!

      6:07 PM 04/17/2012

          
  • vote

    What type of wood is it? Has it been finished in the past?

    9:46 PM 04/17/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

    Comments (1)

    • Sorry, just saw the pics. Looks like pressure treated. I would probably sand out the finish and reapply a pigmented stain.

      9:51 PM 04/17/2012

          
  • vote

    Decks should normally be stained with a "deck" stain. If you definately want to paint it then only use a porch and floor enamel...nothing else! Only porch and floor enamel will hold up but even that will probably have to be re-done in a couple of years. And as a parting thought, never use Behr paint. Forget what Consumers Reports says. I have over 43 years in the paint industry serving mostly commercial clients. The majority of commercial painters use Benjamin-Moore for a good reason...it's reliable and with a proven track record.

    5:29 PM 04/18/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

    Comments (1)

    • I was at the Benjamin Moore in Bay Ridge earlier today and spoke to a very knowledgable and friendly person there. I am going with Benjamin Moore Exterior stain. Now my dilemma is that I have to decide on a color! Thanks for the advice.

      9:59 PM 04/18/2012

          
  • vote

    I prefer Benjamin Moore to most, definitely to behr.  Being a local boy originally, ben has the market share here.  Having grown up elsewhere, where sherwin, not sherman, williams was more common, I used plenty of it years ago, and at least back then, they had good products, too. 

    5:37 PM 04/18/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    And be careful of paint that is called stain. They sell it for houses with unstained clapboard. But it is really paint, despite the name.  google it and read up on it before you go shopping for stain.

    5:40 PM 04/18/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    Forget that...it looks like you have the paint like stain on there already...

    6:26 PM 04/18/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

  • vote

    I just re-stained my deck today.  First time it needed to be stained (2007), I did lots of googling to find out all I could.  You should try that, but be prepared for some conflicting info regarding prep!  Back then, all agreed that the most opaque stains hold up the longest (3-5 years) and oil stains are the best.  I couldn't get the stain here that I wanted but it was available on-line.  At that time, Cabot was highly recommended and that's what I've been using.  Good luck! 

    7:16 PM 04/18/2012 | 0 Votes

     

     

Answer